ENIGMA
ROSS HARRIS – Concerto for Orchestra (World Premiere)
CAMILLE SAINT-SAËNS – Piano Concerto No. 5 “Egyptian” Op.103
EDWARD ELGAR – Variations on an Original Theme – “Enigma” Op.36
Sir Stephen Hough (piano)
Gemma New (conductor)
New Zealand Symphony Orchestra
Michael Fowler Centre, Wellington
Friday 13th November, 2026
Review for “Middle C” by Peter Mechen
What a cornucopia! A veritable torrent of ear-catching, scalp-prickling and pulse-racing sounds, right from the beginning, the “serried ranks” of orchestral players springing to action en masse in response to NZSO conductor Gemma New’s characteristic balletically-delivered initial downbeat – and then, in response to continued semaphoric signallings from the podium, instigating a delightfully enthralling sequence of strategically-placed sonic events designed to mesmerize us with the maximum immediate effect regarding primary thematic character, rhythm, colour and timbre…….whew!! – well, anyway, that was the gist of the effect on this listener of the explosive opening of Ross Harris’s Concerto for Orchestra (commissioned by the NZSO) which began the concert, and this evening, received its WORLD PREMIERE performance on – wait for it! – Friday 13th in Wellington’s Michael Fowler Centre! It was as if Gemma New and the NZSO players had simply opened the orchestral throttle at the work’s beginning and let-er-rip!! As someone wrote in a poem, once – “the achieve of, the mastery of the thing!”
Of course, there was a lot more to what we heard than merely those opening measures of the work – having never heard the music before (along with the rest of a similarly galvanised audience!) I was soon immersed in the intricacies of the composer’s inventiveness and fluency – at the concert’s beginning Ross Harris was brought onto the orchestral platform by Gemma New to say a few words to us about his piece, and I remember him mentioning the name of Bela Bartok as the composer who had written the most well-known “Concerto for Orchestra”, a work which he said he admired but wouldn’t be trying to copy! He certainly had his own compositional ideas, as a glance at the programme indicated, with its movement divisions naming the different orchestral families – woodwinds, strings and brass – with the percussion adding colour throughout. His quoted words to us regarding our listening were “….keep an open mind, and enjoy watching a fantastic orchestra going through its paces…” Harris, of course has a history of “inside knowledge” regarding orchestras, having played the horn in days of yore in this same orchestra’s ranks! – so it was with heightened expectations that we awaited what he had concocted for our pleasure on this occasion.
Harris’s published schema for his Concerto read, simply, “Introduction / Woodwind/ Strings / Brass/ Conclusion” and with the movements linked, which was designed to add to the music’s flow and excitement – it made for quite a different conception to Bartok’s five-movement “darkness to light” overall plan, moving from “the sternness of the first movement and the lugubrious death-song of the third, to the life-assertion of the finale…”. Another feature of Bartok’s was the Concerto’s palindrome form, the work’s central slow movement flanked by two scherzo-like pieces, which were in turn enclosed within two larger ones.
With the rise in orchestral virtuosity during the nineteenth century, musicians became more interested in their instruments’ solo capabilities, encouraging composers to write increasingly for both solo and smaller groups within the orchestra itself. Orchestral music also became increasingly theatrical, “loosening the monolith of the whole”, as one commentator put it, encouraging players’ individual virtuosity all the more. This development could be seen in more progressive quarters as a metaphor for societal and political harmony, and flourished in the works of the great orchestrators such as Rimsky-Korsakov, Mahler, Richard Strauss and Elgar. Their music paved the way for the process to reach fruition in the idea of the “Concerto for Orchestra”, which was put into practice even before Bartok’s work came along and securely validated the form in the minds of the general musical public – works with the title “Concerto for Orchestra” had already appeared from the pens of established composers such as Paul Hindemith, Zoltan Kodaly and Albert Roussel before Bartok’s extraordinary success with his work in Boston in 1944.
This performance was, I thought, a great success in terms of its reception at the end, but also regarding what seemed like the music’s fluency – as the composer himself told us, it felt and sounded like “a fantastic orchestra going through its paces” – and I wondered to what extent it was the work of a composer whose own first-hand experience of orchestral playing enabled a real “sense” of what would work well, and not just for his own instrument but those of his colleagues as well. By that I don’t at all wish to imply that any of the writing was facile or formulaic – instead I thought his responses to orchestral writing were probably in part osmotic due to his experiences and their ingraining as regards his composing.
Despite being not entirely certain of changeover points negotiated by the orchestral “families” one was able to register enough of the play in the orchestral midfield to follow a broad brush-stroke sound-plan, despite a myriad of instrumental details generated by those aforementioned osmotic association on the composer’s part!! The work’s attention-grabbing opening straightaway threw up a chatterbox torrent of dovetailing wind figures with a prominent oboe line and conversational brass colourings, underpinned by percussion touches and a string sostenuto. The composer having thus “called the orchestral roll”, the winds piped up and swung into waltz-time with the oboe , trumpet and horn commenting approvingly – a winsome flute, and a rhapsodic cor anglais both stimulate interest from the percussion of the xylophone/marimba variety. Trumpets and horns briefly frolic with the percussion before the big brass brings some gravitas to which the strings add agreement. The winds haven’t yet done, indulging in rapid-fire exchanges and employing their own inherent characterising qualities to express singular interactions – such as the drollery of the solo bassoon mock-serenading with a marimba, followed by a circumspect flute commenting on the weather with an equally languid oboe predicting a change afoot..….
Then came the strings, introducing themselves with enchantingly spacious extra-terrestrial sounds augment by winds in counterpoint. A quixotic solo from the first violin (Vesa Matti Leppannen strutting his much-admired stuff as a soloist and orchestra leader) led to what I felt was an inclination of the strings to seek and emphasise partnership as much as, if not more than individual or genre-based lines. Here, for instance, the solo violin brought in stratospheric trumpets and galloping percussion, before connecting with a soaring horn and a contra-bassoon – such ear-catching contrasts of timbre and tone seemed to emphasise the collegiality of the orchestral experience at that point rather than “isolate” the impulses and their inclinations.
This was the cue of sorts for the brass to open up, aided and abetted by trajectorial percussive rumblings, with fanfares and ceremonial calls breaking out in ostinato fashion – I loved the exchanges between the different instruments, contrasting the lighter trumpets and horns with the outlandishly monstrous snorts from the heavier brass, the whole building up to a stressful-sounding climax including the tocsin sounding from the depths. The piccolo then called everybody, heavyweights included, smartly to attention for what seemed to shape up as a grand finale! My descriptive powers at this point were flattened in a tsunami of interactive exuberance from all sides, and I had to philosophically concede descriptive defeat for that moment (or, perhaps more accurately, quit while I was behind!). But I was left at the end with an enormous longing to hear the work again in the hopefully not-too-distant future. In the meantime Ross Harris’s “Concerto for Orchestra” can claim honourable membership of the “List” of versions completed, with, on my copy, a couple of “must hear again soon!” asterisks as constant reminders!
French pianist Pascal Roge, touring New Zealand in 1986, included on his itinerary a most welcomed visit to Palmerston North, on which occasion I heard him play Camille Saint-Saëns’ Fifth Piano Concerto with the NZSO and Thomas Sanderling at the Opera House. At that stage I wasn’t familiar with the work, and can well remember Roge, Sanderling and the players electrifying us with the spectacular brilliance of their playing of the concerto’s final movement. I’ve since gotten to know the work a little better, intrigued by the composer’s “exotic” sub-titling of the work as the “Egyptian” (only the middle movement has any of the exoticism one might expect from that title), and disconcerted by the markedly different character of the three movements (though the better-known Second Piano Concerto also has three radically dissimilar movements!). This evening’s soloist, Sir Stephen Hough brought the “Egyptian” with him on his New Zealand tour this year, and performed it for our pleasure in this concert.
Saint-Saëns’ keyboard facility was legendary, with his concertante keyboard works (including five piano concertos) testifying to his brilliance at the keyboard, though he himself played down the flamboyance of the piano-writing. His Fifth Piano Concerto certainly attests to his love of travel, the work’s opening conjuring up a “voyaging” kind of aspect right from the beginning, bringing together excitement and relaxation, charm and bustling energy – Hough’s incredible incandescence of touch evident in the swiftest, most wraith-like of passages, next to which the charm and warmth of his tone serve the music’s beguiling ebb and flow at all points. The NZSO players, too, matched their soloist with whatever degree of application the music required, most crucially in the gossamer lightness and surety of the work’s dancing sequences throughout the opening movement.
What a contrast was presented by the second movement’s tautly-etched rhythms, the pianist’s declamations robustly matching the orchestra’s robust rhythms, the drama of confrontation explored as piano and orchestra picked their intensely dramatic pathways through a colourful, constantly evolving soundscape – a central lyrical exchange between soloist and orchestra quixotically shifted between light and shade, conversation and ritual, Western and Eastern modes – from this grew an exotically-flavoured gamelan-like sequence which conjured up a world far removed from the first movement’s well-mannered relative familiarities, one which slipped mysteriously into the silences at the movement’s end!
The music’s vibrant “magic carpet” simulator again worked its spell as the piano broke suddenly into a spirited canter, drawing the orchestra irresistibly along in its wake, exuberantly expressing what its composer called “the joy of a sea crossing” – the trajectories spectacularly skimming the surfaces of the oceanic vistas suggested by the soaring melodies, then digging into the driving rhythms of the ship’s engines, thrusting us either seawards or skywards as rhythm and melody share the excitement of the journey. Hough’s playing brilliantly fused the two, driving the music towards its spectacularly exhilarating conclusion, as overwhelmingly as I remember Pascal Roge also did in Palmerston North all those years ago!The audience response to all of this was adulatory, calling Stephen Hough repeatedly back to the platform until he was persuaded to help us “return some of the way” to our lives by playing a restoratively tranquil Chopin Nocturne, Op.9 No. 2 in E-flat Major – balm for our somewhat hyperventilated sensibilities in the wake of the incredible Saint-Saens performance!
So after a suitably animated half-time huddle in a foyer buzzing with exuberant delight at the show so far, we trouped back for a second half which promised a different, more personalised, and rather more sobering kind of splendour, Edward Elgar’s “Enigma” Variations, a work which had relatively recently taken on increased significance for New Zealanders regarding a connection with one of the work’s long-standing “mysteries”. This was the identity of the subject of Variation XIII, represented by three dots in the score (the other subjects all have either names or initials), and long supposed to represent an aristocratic acquaintance of the composer, Lady Mary Lygon, who had gone on a sea-voyage, hence the allusion to the sea and the ship’s engines and Mendelssohn’s Overture “Calm Sea and Prosperous Voyage” – more recent researchings have indicated that the three dots instead hid the identity of Elgar’s once-fiancée Helen Jessie Weaver, who had broken off her engagement to the composer and emigrated to New Zealand for health reasons in 1885!
Memories of Innumerable recordings and a handful of past performances gathered to haunt my sensibilities as conductor Gemma New, in her flowing, distinctively-balletic way brought to life the meditative opening of Elgar’s work, a reading which captured both a rapt stillness and gently-flowing pulses, the ‘cellos reaching outwards to us all, then falling back again into thoughtfulness and remembrance. The first variation, C.A.E. brought to us Elgar’s wife Alice, the trajectories lively, with winds graceful and demure, strings at first circumspect and then passionately augmenting the brass’s forthright, all-embracing delivery of the theme, before tending to the winds’ solicitous echoing of the same at the end.
Then came the composer’s tributes to friends, musical portrayals highlighting a plethora of characteristics and specific occurrences both distinctive and diverse. Elgar took pains to point out that they were not “portraits” as such but impressions founded upon distinct “ideas” or incidents known in some cases only to two people. They ranging from lovable out-and-out eccentricity through winsome attractiveness, abruptness of manner, vigorous physicality, generosity of spirit,and appreciation of beauty through to those few which pay tribute to depth of friendship and of feelings not easily forgotten over time (such as the truly enigmatic reference to a lost love of the composer’s already referred to – here,incidentally, most dramatically and sensitively realised!).
Throughout, conductor and players drew us into an enchantingly kaleidoscopic realm of incident and feeling involving a creative artist and his most distinctive and resonant associations with people in his world. My “singling out” the performance of any of the variations reduces not a whit the excellence of the whole’s achievement, but underlines the capacities of New and her players to reflect the work’s beautifully-wrought variation of atmosphere, colour and intensity – so that the fifth Moderato R.P.A.(Richard Penrose Arnold) featured the most sublime string-playing at the outset, followed by gorgeously winsome wind-playing, and the string melody repeated with exquisite balancings of the brass, which led me to marvel all over again at the composer’s orchestrations, especially when this was followed by the Andantino Ysobel with its engaging viola solos, and then the rumbustious timpani-led Presto Troyte! – what brilliance of co-ordinated attack, here, and what stinging accuracy from the strings, and blustering energies from the brass! Wonderful!
Ultimately, though, it’s Elgar’s concluding self-portrait variation, Allegro Presto E.D.U. which clinches any performance, and with the unexpected help of a visually diminutive but unexpectedly impactful chamber organ, conductor and players built the finale’s vigorous and vital series of crescendi with irresistible flow towards a resounding and heartwarming conclusion. What better way to be sent from a concert than babbling with excitement out into the street, replete with the impact of an evening’s give-it-all-you’ve-got music-making!
ATOLL ACD 877 Ross Harris – Song-Cycles – Moriamur and Songs for Dark Times
Helene Pohl (violin) and Rolf Gjelsten (‘cello)
Wellington Youth Orchestras present: –